|
Deck Blocks verses
In-Ground Footings

My
name is Rick Ayotte and I have been building decks for 22 years. My company
has never used
deck blocks. I routinely go back and look at decks I built that are at
least 10 years old to
see if I could learn something from them. I found these decks to be level
and sound. I
learnt not to change the in-ground footing method because it works.
I
don't want to write any libelous statements here so I'll
just deal in empirical* facts.
*empirical;
evidence obtained from observation and experience
rather than theories.
I went
out and inspect decks built by others who used deck blocks. All were off level
some
more than others. Some long decks were "wavy." Areas of top soil
less dense explained why some deck blocks sank a bit causing the
deck to
have
depressions in some areas. Some decks were so bad that they could serve
as a launch
platform for a skateboarder. One of these decks was only a year old.
DECK
BLOCKS - These are good for temporary platforms
that
are used for a few months or a year and then taken apart. A deck at the back of
a house should not be considered as a temporary structure.
Because a deck is unprotected and exposed to weather it may
not have a lifespan like the house it's attached to but with
pressure treated joists and in ground footings it can last
30 years. With deck blocks just the weight of the wood alone
can off set the level of the deck then one would need to
crawl in the dirt under the deck to jack up and shim it
level again. Heavy rain and frost will cause the top surface
of the ground to shrink, swell or erode causing movement
with deck blocks off setting the deck floor.
INABILITY TO CONFRONT - Someone came out with the "idea"
that deck blocks are all you need to build a deck, that they
are sound, reliable, fast to use, cheap to buy and all the
"reasons" and rhetoric that went with it. Underneath all
these "reasons" is simply an
inability to confront drilling a hole and doing it right.
TIME -
For example a deck that needs 8 footings takes about 2 hours
to do the in-ground footings. With deck blocks one would be
at it for hours, preparing the area for the deck blocks,
leveling, shimming and then reveling after a ton of wood is
on the blocks. A contractor who can't confront drilling
holes uses deck blocks which end up being a more complicated
method with the consequent adverse effects past on to the
client. A satisfied customer is a valuable asset and
deserves to have a valuable long lasting product.
Think about
it for a minute.
Would you buy a house that was just placed on the ground? Any unstable area
would cause
structural damage with drywall cracking etc. Building a deck
is an
investment of thousands of dollars and should not be
constructed in a jerry-built fashion.
For
someone to say that deck blocks are good for deck building
is uttering a falsehood and has not inspected anything. Even if
10 people tell
you that deck blocks are good for permanent decks does not make it a fact, it
only makes 10 falsehoods! A deck is an investment and should be built properly
for many, many years of enjoyment and that's a fact. WHO EVER
BUILDS YOUR DECK INSIST ON IN-GROUND FOOTINGS.
|